Where to Sell Beanie Babies for Cash in 2024

Gravatar for Enoch Omololu
Written by Enoch Omololu
Updated on

Dollar Financials is reader-supported. This means we may earn a commission if you click to sign-up or make a purchase.  Read our disclosure.

Looking to sell your Beanie Babies? From marketplaces like eBay and Craigslist to collector websites like Sell2BBNovelties.com, there are plenty of options for where to sell Beanie Babies online. 

Maximize your sales by checking out price guides to determine their value, taking clear photos, and writing detailed descriptions.

Keep reading so that you can get the best possible price for your beloved Beanie Babies.

Where to Sell Beanie Babies Online

1. Etsy

Selling Process: Create an Etsy shop and list your Beanie Babies with detailed descriptions, prices, and images.

What They Accept: Unique and collectible Beanie Babies.

Fees: They charge listing fees as well as transaction fees for each successful sale.

Pros: Gain access to a niche market of collectors. Also, take advantage of their customizable shop design.

Cons: Competition from other sellers and fees can cut into profits.

2. eBay

Selling Process: Set up an eBay account, create listings with descriptions and photos, and choose auction or fixed-price formats.

What They Accept: A wide range of Beanie Babies.

Fees: They charge a variety of fees, like Insertion fees, Final Value fees, and Optional Upgrade fees.

Pros: They have a large and diverse audience, which has the potential for competitive bids.

Cons: Competition can impact pricing, and fees can accumulate.

3. Ruby Lane

Selling Process: Open a shop on Ruby Lane and list your rare Beanie Babies with detailed descriptions.

What They Accept: High-quality and unique collectibles.

Fees: They charge a monthly membership fee and service fees.

Pros: Their platform is curated for high-end collectibles and a focused audience.

Cons: Membership fees and their platform are limited to high-end items.

4. Sell2BBNovelties.com

Selling Process: Submit a list of items you want to sell, receive a quote, and ship the items. You will receive the payment within one week.

What They Accept: Well-preserved Beanie Babies.

Fees: No fees, as they will purchase the item from you directly.

Pros: You can quickly find your Beanie Baby’s value using the barcode’s last 5 digits in their unique lookup library. Also, you have the option to sell in bulk.

Cons: You might receive lower offers for bulk items.

5. Mercari

Selling Process: Download the Mercari app in order to list your Beanie Babies, set prices, and manage inquiries.

What They Accept: Beanie Babies of various conditions.

Fees: They charge a 10% sales fee, and sellers shoulder the shipping fee.

Pros: Free to list and user-friendly app. Has the potential for quick sales.

Cons: The commission fee is on the high end as compared to other platforms.

Related: Mercari vs. eBay.

6. Sell4Value

Selling Process: Apply first and receive a quote. Once you accept, your item will be shipped to their headquarters, and you’ll receive the agreed amount in your bank account.

What They Accept: Beanie Babies that are in mint condition and other collectibles.

Fees: There are no fees, as they’ll buy the items directly from you. 

Pros: They provide upfront appraisals and quotes, which is a convenient and transparent process.

Cons: Offers might be slightly lower in exchange for convenience.

7. Bonanza

Selling Process: Go to the “Start selling” page, choose a name for your booth, click “Open your booth,” select your preferred payment method, and enter your personal details.

What They Accept: Beanie Babies in pristine condition and other collectibles.

Fees: They charge a listing fee of $0.25 and a seller’s fee of 3.5% for those who don’t have an active subscription.

Pros: Customizable shop design as well as fixed-price listings.

Cons: Fees can eat into your profits and consume valuable time invested in managing your shop.

Where to Sell Beanie Babies Near You

8. Facebook Marketplace

Selling Process: List your Beanie Babies on Facebook Marketplace and communicate with buyers through Facebook Messenger or other messaging platforms.

What They Accept: A wide variety of items, including Beanie Babies, stuffed animals, and collectibles.

Fees: There are no listing fees.

Pros: Local audience, so you can reach people who live nearby and avoid long-distance shipping costs. Also, no listing fees mean you can save money on selling your items.

Cons: Safety concerns may arise when meeting strangers in person, and negotiating prices and terms with buyers may be necessary, which can be time-consuming.

9. Craigslist Yard Sales 

Selling Process: Participate in local yard sales, display your Beanie Babies to draw in customers, and enjoy face-to-face interactions for quick transactions.

What They Accept: Items for yard sale, including Beanie Babies, stuffed animals, and collectibles.

Fees: Yard sale costs, if applicable (e.g., table rental, advertising).

Pros: Face-to-face interactions allow for better communication and build trust with buyers.  Also, immediate transactions mean you won’t have to wait for payment.

Cons: Time investment in setting up and attending yard sales. Negotiation with buyers may be required, which can be challenging for some sellers.

10. OfferUp

Selling Process: List your Beanie Babies on OfferUp, connect with local buyers, and arrange meetups. 

What they accept: Various items for sale, including Beanie Babies.

Fees:  The service fee is 12.9% of the final sale price, excluding shipping costs, with a minimum of $1.99.

Pros: Local audience and geolocation feature for targeted exposure, and high potential for profit margins due to lower fees.

Cons: Safety concerns for in-person meetups and negotiations, as well as a lack of buyer protection and guarantees.

Related: Best sites like OfferUp.

11. Pawn Shops

Selling Process: Visit local pawn shops and offer them your Beanie Babies. These businesses often have customers looking for affordable collectibles.

What They Accept: A wide range of items for resale, including Beanie Babies.

Fees: None for sellers. 

Pros: Transactions are quick and straightforward. In addition, pawn shops and consignment stores often have a large customer base, which increases your chances of selling your items quickly.

Cons: Offers might be lower than market value. Additionally, these businesses tend to be more interested in items that are in high demand and in good condition, so you may not get as much for your Beanie Babies if they are damaged or not as popular. 

12. Local Collectible Shops

Selling Process: Visit local collectible shops and present your Beanie Babies for sale. These specialty stores cater to collectors and enthusiasts.

What They Accept: Collectible items, including Beanie Babies, are the primary focus of these stores. 

Fees: Some shops might take a commission. You may be charged a flat fee, a percentage of the sale price, or a combination of both. 

Pros: Personalized interaction with knowledgeable staff who understand the value of collectible items. Also, you may receive fairer offers because of the shop’s expertise and existing clientele. 

Cons: Limited reach compared to online platforms and potentially lower offers due to overhead costs and profit margins. Also, may not have as many clients as online marketplaces, which could result in fewer offers for your Beanie Babies.

How to Sell Beanie Babies

Selling Beanie Babies can be a breeze if you follow these simple steps:

  • Assessment: Give your Beanie Babies a once-over to check their condition and potential value.
  • Research: Use a variety of online resources and price guides to gauge what your Beanie Babies are worth.
  • Photography: Capture clear, well-lit photos that highlight your Beanie Babies’ best features. A picture’s worth a thousand words, after all.
  • Listing: Create compelling and accurate listings that provide buyers with all the details they need, including prices and shipping information.
  • Communication: Respond promptly to potential buyers’ queries and be open to price negotiations if the situation calls for it.
  • Shipping: Safeguard your Beanie Babies by packaging them securely before shipping to ensure they reach their new homes safely.

Selling Beanie Babies Price Guide

Before you jump into the selling frenzy, take the time to consult Beanie Babies price guides

These guides will help you pinpoint the market value of your items, considering factors like rarity, condition, and tag errors.

Beanie Babies Wanted List

Wondering which Beanie Babies are super popular among collectors? Look for lists of wanted items online. These lists show which Beanie Babies are in high demand, so you can focus on selling those ones. 

Plus, you can check out online forums and groups where collectors talk about what they’re looking for and how much they’re willing to spend. This helps you set the right price for your beanies and attract more buyers.


How do I find out what my Beanie Babies are worth? 

Arm yourself with knowledge by researching online price guides, tapping into collector forums, and scouting recent sales.

What can I do with my old Beanie Babies? 

Your options include selling them for cash, donating them to spread joy, or giving them as gifts.

Does anyone buy Beanie Babies anymore? 

Yes. Collectors and enthusiasts still have a soft spot for Beanie Babies, especially if they’re unique or rare.

How can you tell if a Ty Beanie Baby is rare? 

Keep an eye out for limited production numbers, distinctive design elements, and rare tag errors.



Get paid to answer surveys, shop online, surf the internet, play games, and watch videos. Get a $10 welcome bonus.

Get a $10 sign-up bonus when you join and complete your first online purchase of $20 or more. Get paid to shop and more. (US/Can only).

Work as a proofreader from home and earn up to $40/hour. Get all you need to start your online proofreading business with a top-rated course!

No current offers for this category.

Gravatar for Enoch Omololu

Enoch Omololu

Enoch Omololu is a personal finance expert who has a passion for helping others win with their finances. He has a master’s degree in Finance and Investment Management from the University of Aberdeen Business School and has been writing about money management for over a decade. Enoch has been featured in several leading personal finance publications including MSN Money, The Globe and Mail, Wealthsimple, and the Financial Post.

Leave a Comment

Get a sign-up bonus when you join and get paid to complete short surveys.