FacebookTweetPin

16 Best Places to Sell Sports Cards for Cash: Online & In-Person

Gravatar for Enoch Omololu
Written by Enoch Omololu
Updated on

Dollar Financials is reader-supported. This means we may earn a commission if you click to sign-up or make a purchase.  Read our disclosure.

Looking to turn your sports card collection into cash, and wondering where to sell your cards for the best value? 

Whether you’re searching for the best place to sell sports cards near you or looking to sell them online. This guide will help you navigate the world of sports card selling. 

Where to Sell Sports Cards for Cash Online

1. eBay

Selling Process: List your cards with descriptions and photos. Bidders compete in auctions or purchase through Buy It Now listings.

Accepted Cards: A wide range of sports cards, from vintage to modern.

Fees: Typically, 10–15% of the final value is charged. Your first 250 listings are free each month, after which there is a $0.35 insertion charge per listing.

Pros: Large audience; potential for high prices.

Cons: Fees can add up, and competition can affect prices.

2. OfferUp

Selling Process: Create listings with photos and descriptions on their online platform. Buyers can now contact you directly for negotiations. It is also available on the Google Play and Apple App Stores.

Accepted Cards: Various sports cards

Fees: There are no listing fees, but fees apply to each transaction.

Pros: Local sales and easy communication. Buyers are responsible for the shipping costs.

Cons: Limited to local buyers.

You can also check out these sites like OfferUp.

3. Alt

Selling Process: Snap photos, upload, and list. Buyers can make offers or purchase directly because there are two methods of selling: fixed price and auction.

Accepted Cards: A wide range of sports cards.

Fees: They charge a 5% commission on all sales made through the site, as well as a one-time $5 service fee for non-investment-grade cards for safekeeping in their vault.

Pros: User-friendly app and parallel listing of your cards on eBay; potential for quick sales.

Cons: Limited to specific cards and markets.

4. Otia

Selling Process: Contact them via email, phone, or the Contact Us form on their website, providing pictures, an asking price, and a brief description of the cards you have for sale. Once received, Otia will provide their valuation, which is valid for 30 days.

Accepted Cards: Pays more for vintage cards (defined as cards manufactured before 1975) than competitors.

Fees: No listing fees, as they will buy from you directly.

Pros: User-friendly; ability to negotiate.

Cons: Smaller user base compared to bigger platforms.

5. Dave & Adam’s Card World

Selling Process: To sell items on the site, browse the buy list and select the items you want to sell using the “Sell to us” option. Then, review your sell list and fill out your contact information and preferred payment method.

Accepted Cards: A wide variety of sports cards.

Fees: No fees apply, as they are the ones buying from you.

Pros: Professional appraisal; hassle-free process.

Cons: Offers may be lower than expected.

6. Beckett

Selling Process: Organize your collection using the “Organize” section on its site and then click the “Selling” button. You can now set your price and list your cards.

Accepted Cards: Rookie cards, memorabilia cards, and signature cards are just a few examples.

Fees: Grading fees and listing fees.

Pros: Premium for graded cards; reputation.

Cons: Not friendly to beginners because it requires grading expertise.

7. Kruk Cards

Selling Process: Contact them via phone or email, or use their Contact Us form on their website. After confirmation, bring or ship the cards to Kruk for payment.

Accepted Cards: A wide range of sports cards.

Fees: Varies based on collection.

Pros: Personalized offers; trusted reputation.

Cons: Offers may vary, leading to lower prices for your cards.

8. Check Out My Collectibles (COMC)

Selling Process: Create a free account and send your card collection to COMC. Once they receive the cards and set the selling price, they will handle everything else, including listing, packaging, and shipping.

Accepted Cards: A wide variety of sports cards.

Fees: Charges a listing fee, transaction fee, and cash out fee.

Pros: Professional listing; access to a wide audience.

Cons: Long processing times; fees can eat into your earnings.

9. StockX

Selling Process: List your item with a minimum price. When a buyer agrees to the sale, you must send the item to StockX for verification. Once verified, the item will be released to the buyer, and you’ll receive payment through various methods.

Accepted Cards: Various sports cards.

Fees: Charges a 3% payment processing fee and transaction fees depending on your Seller Level.

Pros: Similar to a stock market for cards, there is potential for competitive prices. Also, access to a global market.

Cons: Fees can impact your profit margin; potential for lowball offers.

10. TonyeTrade

Selling Process: Fill out the contact form on their website, or call or email them. If the offered price is good, send the cards to TonyeTrade and receive payment.

Accepted Cards: Specializes in vintage baseball and sports cards.

Fees: Vary depending on the arrangement and card condition.

Pros: User-friendly app; ability to negotiate and get instant offers.

Cons: Fees can be exorbitant; lesser-known platform.


11. PSA Collectibles

Selling Process: Authenticates cards that you uploaded on their forum, where buyers can negotiate with you directly. 

Accepted Cards: PSA-graded cards.

Fees: Card authentication and grading fees.

Pros: Focus on high-quality cards; established reputation.

Cons: Limited to PSA-graded cards.

12. Blowout Cards Forums

Selling Process: A forum for sports card collectors and enthusiasts where members can buy and sell sports cards directly with each other.

Accepted Cards: Old baseball cards, antique sports cards, and rare sports cards.

Fees: Listing is free, but commission fees apply.

Pros: Community-driven; direct interaction between sellers and customers.

Cons: Requires active participation.

Best Places to Sell Sports Cards Near You

13. Yard Sales

Selling Process: Set up a yard sale, display your cards, and negotiate with potential buyers.

Accepted Cards: Varies based on local interest.

Fees: No listing fees; potentially no transaction fees.

Pros: Direct interaction with prospective buyers; quick sales.

Cons: Limited audience; requires local setup.

14. Consignment Stores

Selling Process: Leave your cards at the store; they will handle sales, and you get a portion of the earnings.

Accepted Cards: Depends on the store’s focus.

Fees: Commission-based fees.

Pros: No upfront fees; convenience because most cities have these types of shops.

Cons: Lower earnings due to commission; limited to local market.

15. Facebook Marketplace

Selling Process: Create a Facebook account, post your cards on the Marketplace, and begin receiving offers from potential buyers.

Accepted Cards: A wide range of sports cards.

Fees: There are no fees for a basic listing, but there is a paid option to boost your listing.

Pros: Customizable ads; has a relevance algorithm that surfaces products to match users search queries.

Cons: Limited to local customers; needs extra caution in meeting up with buyers.

16. Craigslist

Selling Process: Create listings for your cards, communicate with potential buyers, and arrange in-person transactions.

Accepted Cards: Various sports cards.

Fees: No listing fees; typically no transaction fees.

Pros: Local sales, direct interaction.

Cons: Limited to local customers; needs extra caution in meeting up with buyers.

Tips on Selling Sports Cards for Cash

Selling your sports cards for cash can be a rewarding endeavor, but it requires careful consideration. Here are some tips to help you achieve your goals:

  • Assess Your Collection: Determine the value and condition of your cards before selling. Valuable cards should be professionally graded to fetch higher prices.
  • Research the Market: Understand the current market trends and prices for the cards you intend to sell.
  • Set Realistic Prices: Price your cards competitively based on their condition, rarity, and demand.
  • Provide Accurate Descriptions: Clearly describe your cards’ condition, including any flaws or imperfections.
  • Take Quality Photos: High-quality images help attract potential buyers and showcase your cards effectively.
  • Choose the Right Platform: Select platforms that align with your selling goals, whether it’s reaching a wide audience or focusing on specific buyers.
  • Consider Fees: Factor in listing and transaction fees when calculating your potential earnings.
  • Engage with Buyers: Promptly respond to inquiries and negotiate respectfully with potential buyers.
  • Safely Handle Transactions: If meeting in person, prioritize safety by meeting in public places during daylight hours.
  • Keep Records: Maintain records of your sales for future reference and organization.

FAQs

How can I tell if my sports cards are worth money? 

Research their current market value, consider their age and condition, and ask experts for guidance. Hold on to them to see if their value changes over time.

Do old sports cards have value? 

Yes, old sports cards can have significant value, especially if they are in good condition and were printed during a specific time period.

Can you scan sports cards for value? 

No, scanning alone doesn’t affect a card’s value. Other factors like rarity, condition, and athlete performance matter most.

What is the most a sports card has sold for? 

The Mickey Mantle 1952 Topps baseball card sold for $12.6 million in August 2022. Another notable sports card is the 1909 T206 Honus Wagner baseball card, which sold for $7.25 million.

Related:

Pin

Get paid to answer surveys, shop online, surf the internet, play games, and watch videos. Get a $10 welcome bonus.

Get a $10 sign-up bonus when you join and complete your first online purchase of $20 or more. Get paid to shop and more. (US/Can only).

Work as a proofreader from home and earn up to $40/hour. Get all you need to start your online proofreading business with a top-rated course!

No current offers for this category.

Gravatar for Enoch Omololu

Enoch Omololu

Enoch Omololu is a personal finance expert who has a passion for helping others win with their finances. He has a master’s degree in Finance and Investment Management from the University of Aberdeen Business School and has been writing about money management for over a decade. Enoch has been featured in several leading personal finance publications including MSN Money, The Globe and Mail, Wealthsimple, and the Financial Post.

Leave a Comment

EXCLUSIVE OFFER
Join the best survey site and earn gift cards and PayPal cash from your couch.